Report

Rewriting the Rules of Progress

Submission to the Intergovernmental Process on Beyond GDP

For decades, gross domestic product (GDP) has been the main measure of economic progress and has shaped decisions on budgets, finance and development. It says little about whether growth improves people's lives, who benefits, or whether progress can last within the limits of the planet. The UN's intergovernmental process on Beyond GDP is a chance to change this.

In a submission to the call for contributions to the process's Elements Paper, UNU-CPR argues that the process should aim for an institutional shift, not a symbolic one; a new standard for measuring progress that governments, the UN system and financial institutions actually use when they make decisions.

The submission builds on the framework proposed by the High-Level Expert Group on Beyond GDP and calls for it to be refined and completed. It identifies gaps that still need work: headline indicators, cross-border spillovers, comprehensive wealth accounting, planetary boundaries, the effects of technological change, and how the framework will be applied by international financial institutions.

Structured around the call's four themes, the submission sets out five priorities:

  • Adopt a UN dashboard as a standard for policymaking. It should measure inclusive and sustainable wellbeing for current and future generations, and be used in budgeting, lawmaking and policy evaluation.
  • Make the UN Statistical Commission the framework's custodian. An expert group under the Commission would identify, validate and regularly review indicators. It would draw on academic, policy, Indigenous, civil society and private sector expertise, and work alongside science-policy platforms across the UN system.
  • Balance global coherence with national ownership. All countries would share one conceptual framework, choose domains and indicators to fit their own priorities and capacities, and follow common guidance on measurement methods.
  • Develop a small set of headline indicators through a legitimate process. One to three indicators should be comparable across countries, used by institutions and relevant for citizens. Newer measures, such as planetary boundaries and cross-border spillover effects, should have a transparent route to international acceptance.
  • Create implementation mechanisms and mainstream across financing. Countries, especially developing countries, need support to strengthen their statistical systems. International financial institutions and credit rating agencies should reflect the Beyond GDP framework in their own assessments, including debt sustainability analysis. Without this, many countries will have little incentive to invest in the approach.

The submission also calls for a mapping of how Beyond GDP connects with existing frameworks, including the 2030 Agenda, the Multidimensional Vulnerability Index and the Sevilla Commitment. The goal is for Beyond GDP to support and offer coherence to implementing existing commitments rather than add another standalone mandate. A framework meant to support inclusive, transparent and accountable decision-making should, the submission argues, be governed in the same way.