Working Paper

Could Commercial Presence Substitute Cross-Border Services Trade? A Mechanism Behind the Stagnation of Services Tradesphere of Influence

Abstract

This paper examines one of the mechanisms that may explain why services trade is not taking off by analysing the effect of International Investment Agreements (IIAs) on sector-specific bilateral service trade, using the Poisson Pseudo-likelihood regression model with Multiple Levels of High-Dimensional Fixed Effects (PPMLHDFE) to estimate the gravity equations. The findings provide empirical evidence of a negative correlation—and thus a substitution effect—between Treaties with Investment Provisions (TIPs) and Bilateral Investment Treaties (BITs), which serve as proxies for commercial presence due to their role in fostering FDI and cross-border trade in services. The sector-by-sector analysis suggests that the expansion of mode three of supply may have come at the expense of mode one, hindering overall services trade as businesses prioritised establishing a physical presence over remote service delivery, particularly in sectors such as telecommunications, computer, and information services, insurance and pension services, intellectual property, and transport. However, the balance may be shifting, potentially making the need for commercial presence obsolete as cross-border services can increasingly be provided at arm’s length.

Related content

Report

Rewriting the Rules of Progress

Submission to the Intergovernmental Process on Beyond GDP

Seminar

Humanitarian Action Today

The UNU-MERIT Seminar Series is pleased to announce an upcoming research seminar featuring Thea Hilhorst, Professor of Humanitarian Studies at the International Institute of Social Studies (ISS), Erasmus University Rotterdam. Her research focuses on humanitarian aid in contexts of conflict, disaster, and fragility, with particular attention to humanitarian governance and aid–society relations.

-

News

UNU-CRIS Contributes to the Routledge Companion to International Law and Responsible Business

Publication Alert: Contribution of the Chapter on "Regional Economic Integration and Responsible Business" is now online and is open access.

13 Nov 2026