Commentary

Water Bankruptcy, Justice, and the Danger of False Dichotomies

A Response to Rusca et al. “The Limits of the Water Bankruptcy Framing Call for a Water Justice Response”

Date Published
16 Nov 2026
Author
UNU-INWEH

Abstract

In a Comment published in Nature Water, Rusca et al. question the water bankruptcy framing and argue that its limitations call for a water justice response. This response by the United Nations University Institute for Water, Environment and Health (UNU-INWEH) examines their principal criticisms in light of the formal definition of water bankruptcy and its foundational publications. It clarifies that water bankruptcy is a scientifically defined condition of human–water systems, characterized by persistent hydrological overshoot and irreversible degradation of water-related natural capital, rather than merely a metaphor for water scarcity. The response demonstrates that several concerns presented as overlooked, including human agency, political economy, unequal responsibilities, technological fixes, accountability, equity, and justice, are explicitly addressed in the foundational publications. It also questions whether the empirical evidence presented in the Comment substantiates its criticisms. While welcoming further scholarly development of the framework, UNU-INWEH emphasizes that opportunities to extend a scientific concept should not be confused with evidence of its shortcomings, and that scholarly criticism must accurately represent existing research. Water bankruptcy diagnoses a condition; just water transitions guide how societies respond to it fairly and sustainably. The two are complementary, not competing, approaches.
 

Read the full commentary

 

How to cite: UNU-INWEH. “Water Bankruptcy, Justice, and the Danger of False Dichotomies: A Response to Rusca et al., ‘The Limits of the Water Bankruptcy Framing Call for a Water Justice Response’” United Nations University Institute for Water, Environment and Health (UNU-INWEH), 16 November 2026. doi: 10.53328/INB26KAM002