Policy Brief

The Transformation of Comparative Regionalism

Abstract

This Brief illustrates that Comparative Regionalism has recently undergone three ‘silent’ transformations which have moved it beyond the struggle between EU-centric and EU-critical scholarship.

 

Conceptually, scholars disaggregate regionalism into specific components, rendering systematic comparison more tractable and less case-centric.

 

Theoretically, scholars develop frameworks that build on general social science theories and actively seek to overcome EU-centrism (‘integration snobbery’) as well as exaggerated EU-criticism (‘area centricity’).

 

Methodologically, scholars use more rigorous comparative designs and a broader range of data.

 

The benefit of the field’s maturing lies in the intellectual energy generated from being ‘freed-up’ and from the new links formed with other sub-fields.

 

The price of this transformation is three-fold: the risk of covert as opposed to overt EU-centrism, increased barriers to entry and the costs associated with cross-regional data collection, and finally, the risk of ‘gatekeeping’ which threatens the field’s pluralism and diversity.

Related content

News

What is the State of Regionalism today and how to Integrate it in a PhD Project?

A three-day doctoral school exploring conceptual, thematic & global approaches to researching regionalism, organised by Ghent University and UNU-CRIS.

19 Nov 2026

News

Call for Papers | Gulf Research Meeting 2027 Rethinking GCC Regionalism: Interdependence, Shared Challenges and Cooperation in the Gulf

Why does regional cooperation succeed in some areas of the Gulf but remain difficult in others?

18 Nov 2026